17 – The Aurelian

a critical examination of Nabokov's collected stories

In “The Aurelian” (1931) Nabokov returns to his theme of the unexpected arrival of death, and he indulges himself slightly by giving the principal character his own interest in lepidoptery (for which ‘aurelia’ is a now old-fashioned term).

The AurelianPilgram is a pathetic old German who has inherited a not very successful shop from his father. He sells butterflies, but most of his meagre earnings come from the odd bits of stationery he sells to schoolboys. He has developed a reputation for his entomology without ever having travelled beyond Berlin, but for years he has nurtured a secret desire to go on a collecting expedition so as to actually see some of his prey in their natural and (to him) exotic surroundings.

When an old lady asks him to sell a collection on her behalf, he cheats her and decides to make his wish come true as quickly as possible. He leaves his wife a curt note saying he has gone to Spain, but when she returns from a wedding later that day she finds him in the shop, dead from a stroke.

Pilgram is one of a number of Nabokov’s characters who meet death unexpectedly – either at a point of happiness (Mark Standfuss in ‘Details of a Sunset’) or as a grotesque surprise (Quilty in Lolita). The problem with Pilgram’s case as far as the reader is concerned is the somewhat ambiguous manner in which he is portrayed.

His scientific idealism and his desire to travel are rather utopian, but we are nevertheless invited to sympathise with the dreams in which “he … visited the islands of the Blessed, where in the hot ravines that cut the lower slopes of the chestnut- and laurel-clad mountains there occurs a weird local race of the cabbage white” (ND, p.103). But he is a rather unpleasant character, and is offensively rude to his wife, to the point that when she annoys him by crying he “toy[s] with the idea of taking an axe and splitting her pale-haired head” (p.106). He cheats the old lady, and he prepares to leave knowing the family will have debts and unpaid taxes.

Germans are not generally portrayed very sympathetically in Nabokov’s work, but Pilgram is particularly unappealing. It seems that it is not his death we are being invited to contemplate so much as its ironic timing – just as ‘the dream of his life was about to break at last from its old crinkly cocoon’ (p.106).

The neat structural division of the story into four distinct sections certainly reinforces this impression. The first describes the pathetically humdrum nature of Pilgram’s daily life; the second his enthusiasm for lepidoptery and his yearning to travel; the third his double-dealing and his preparations for the trip; and the fourth his wife’s return from the wedding.

This last section presents a switch in viewpoint which allows the revelation to be concealed until the last lines of the story – although it has been hinted at in signals beforehand. Earlier in the story Pilgram has felt the first [to us premonitory] tremor ‘like a mountain falling upon him from behind just as he had bent towards his shoestrings’ (p.96).

‘The Aurelian’ illustrates a point made over and again by Nabokov in his critical writings – that it is not the overt subject matter which constitutes the beauty in a work of art so much as the manner in which the details of its composition are arranged.

Paul Pilgram is a nasty old man with unrealistic dreams, but Nabokov does not arrange the story to engineer sympathy for his death so much as to invite our admiration for the manner in which it is told. One small and typically Nabokovian detail demonstrates this point. When an irritating visitor to the shop has been looking at some butterfly specimens

‘It might happen … that some open box, having been brushed by the elbow of the visitor, would stealthily begin to slide off the counter – to be stopped just in the nick of time by Pilgram, who would then calmly go on lighting his pipe; only much later, when busy elsewhere, he would suddenly produce a moan of retrospective anguish’ (p.102)

The threatened accident which doesn’t quite occur: this is a device Nabokov uses regularly in his work (one thinks of Pnin’s dropping nutcrackers onto a glass bowl – which doesn’t break). The reader breathes a sigh of relief with Pilgram. But later when he returns to the counter to grab petty cash for his escape: ‘Pilgram perceived something almost appalling in the richness of the huge happiness which was leaning towards him like a mountain” (p.109). This of course is his final stroke, approaching in the repeated simile of the mountain, and then –

‘catching sight of the hazy money pot … [he] reached quickly for it. The pot slipped from his moist grasp and broke onto the floor with a dizzy spinning of twinkling coins; and Pilgram bent low to pick them up’ (p.109)

So something does fall from the counter after all, and Pilgram bends down just as he did at his first stroke. But this time he does not get up, and that is how his wife finds him: ‘his back to the counter, among scattered coins, his livid face knocked out of shape by death’ (p.111).

These are the sorts of carefully orchestrated details which Nabokov so frequently commended in the work of other writers: ‘This capacity to wonder at trifles … these asides of the spirit, these footnotes in the volume of life are the highest form of consciousness’ (LL,p.374) They are probably the reason why he called his own critical approach ‘a kind of detective investigation of the mystery of literary structures’ (LL,p.1).


© Roy Johnson 2005

Vladimir Nabokov Collected Stories   Vladimir Nabokov: The Collected Stories – Amazon UK
Vladimir Nabokov Collected Stories   Vladimir Nabokov: The Collected Stories – Amazon US

Vladimir Nabokov links

Red button Vladimir Nabokov – life and works

Red button Nabokov’s Complete Short Stories – critical analyses

Red button Vladimir Nabokov: an illustrated life

  • Improve your Writing Skills (.pdf)Improve your Writing Skills

    Improve your writing skills – now! Improve your English and your communication skills. Learn how to write with clarity and style. Choose the most effective vocabulary. Make every word count with clear grammar and punctuation. This eBook will show you how to write effective sentences and paragraphs, plus how to structure your writing. Overcome writer’s […]

    Order Improve your Writing Skills Improve your Writing Skills @ £1.95

Buy from Amazon US     Buy from Amazon UK

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

If you found this article interesting you might want to Tell-A-Friend.

Tell A Friend
  1. (required)
  2. (valid email required)
  3. (required)
  4. (valid email required)

cforms contact form by delicious:days

4 Responses to “17 – The Aurelian”

  1. Alice Schwartz says:

    The wedding is that of the neighbor’s daughter, not Pilgram’s. Of Pilgram and his wife: “They had married in 1905…and were childless…”

  2. mantex says:

    Thank you for that correction Alice. I don’t have the ‘Collected Stories’ at my side just at the moment to double-check the details, but I am sure you are right.

  3. Stephen says:

    I’m going to sound like I’m being difficult but the fact that you thought Pilgram was skipping his own daughter’s wedding (there’s no daughter in the story and more importantly he’s just not that kind of character) calls your essay into question when coupled with your erroneous statement that he died of a heart attack. Dude! Nabokov recalls the stroke incident for us, then just as Pilgram sells the collection he has a violent nosebleed…this is all connected by the imagery of the mountain… A stroke.

  4. Roy Johnson says:

    No – you’re not being difficult Stephen. You force me to read the story again more carefully – for which I am grateful. You’re quite right – it’s not his own but a neighbour’s daughter whose marriage he misses. And what I first describe as a heart attack is in fact a stroke, which is prefigured in the first part of the story. And of course you are again right – the spasm he feels ‘like a mountain falling upon him from behind’ – is the connecting imagery (though to be fair to myself, I do mention this is the piece). I’ve removed the two errors now. Many thanks.

Leave a Reply


Powered by eShop v.6